I believe this post is relevant to remembering and memorializing September 11, 2001.
We all remember where we were when we heard the news. The rest of the day felt like a nightmarish blur as we watched the twin towers collapse and the clouds of dust settle on lower Manhattan.
It's a day I'll never forget.
George W. Bush was the president, and I remember that he actively spoke out against harassing, blaming, or attacking Muslim Americans. He repeatedly emphasized that the attacks were carried out by extremists and did not represent the Islamic religion.
That was the correct thing to do.
Unfortunately, 25 years later, there are still Americans who allow their fears, ignorance, and bigotry to blame ALL Muslims for the 19 fanatical terrorists who perpetrated the unspeakable carnage and destruction on that day.
Our friend and frequent contributor and commenter here at P.E., Dave Miller, recently found the comment below on the Geeez blog; and, it not only shocked him and me, but it made me think that we, as humans never, never learn what history teaches us again and again about blaming an entire religion, culture, or country for the crimes of the fanatical few.
I leave this for you to think about on this 25th anniversary of that terrible day. May we remember those who lost their lives and the first responders who risked theirs to save their fellow human beings. They represent the best in humanity.
The following comment, in my opinion, represents the worst:
Dave did something interesting with the comment. He loaded it into Google AI and asked how Michel Montaigne might've responded to it, based on his famous essay "Of Cannibals" Here's the response Dave got:
********************************
If Michel de Montaigne were alive today and reading this post, his reaction would combine profound grief, intellectual disgust, and an immediate recognition of the exact human flaws he spent his life cataloging.
The quote you shared—borrowing the name of Samuel Huntington, the political scientist famous for the "Clash of Civilizations" theory—is a textbook example of the fanatical certainty and ethnocentric brutality that Montaigne witnessed firsthand during the French Wars of Religion.
Here is how Montaigne, drawing from his philosophy and specifically from Of Cannibals, would dissect and respond to this text:
1. On the Brutality of the "Civilized"
The author of the post frames Muslims as "swine" and casually advocates for the atomic annihilation of hundreds of millions of people during prayer. In Of Cannibals, Montaigne famously argued that Europeans point out the "barbarism" of others while completely ignoring their own monstrous behavior.
Montaigne would look at this post and say:
"We call them barbarians, but we ignore our own savagery. It is far more barbarous to vaporize entire nations of living, breathing families in a 'glorious burst' of radiation than it is to practice ritual cannibalism on a dead enemy in a forest."
To Montaigne, the author has lost their humanity. By advocating for genocide under the guise of "national security" (prevention), the writer proves Montaigne's core thesis: civilized society often invents the most sophisticated, high-tech cruelties.
2. The Danger of Absolute Certainty
Montaigne's lifelong motto was "What do I know?" (Que sais-je?). He believed that human cruelty almost always stems from people believing they possess absolute, unshakeable truth.
The author of the post speaks with total, terrifying conviction—implying that an entire religion is a singular monolith that must be wiped "from the planet." Montaigne would respond:
"How arrogant must a man be to play God? To believe his small, fearful human mind has the right to decide who lives and dies on this earth? True wisdom begins with doubting your own anger."
3. Missing the Mirror
In Of Cannibals, Montaigne used the indigenous people of Brazil as a mirror to show Europeans their own greed, hypocrisy, and inequality. He would see this post as a refusal to look in that mirror.
The author points to "Islamic attacks" to justify total destruction, but Montaigne would remind the writer of Europe's (and the West's) own bloody history:
"You condemn the violence of the other, yet your own solution is a violence so vast it would turn the world to ash. You have become the very monster you claim to fight."
4. The Violation of Hospitality and Curiosity
Montaigne was deeply fascinated by different cultures and religions. He traveled widely, sought out perspectives different from his own, and advocated for open-mindedness. The idea of "barring" an entire group of people based on their faith would strike him as a tragedy of human ignorance. He believed that when we close our borders and our minds to the world, we stop growing and instead fester in our own biases.
💡 The Final Verdict
Montaigne lived in a time when Catholics and Protestants were slaughtering each other in the streets of France, convinced they were doing God's work. He saw where that kind of rhetoric led: to massacres, ash, and the destruction of the soul.
He would view this "Sam Huntington" post not as a modern political opinion, but as the same old, tragic human sickness—fanaticism masking itself as virtue. He would urge the writer to put down their weapons, log off the computer, go outside, and play with their cat until they remembered what it means to be human.
Thank you for this post, Shaw, and Dave. A most appropriate one for this moment in time.
ReplyDeleteThe historical Buddha no doubt agrees.
The blogger "Sam Huntington" post highlights the depth of human potential for Humankinds Inhumanity To Humankind.
The unspeakable thought that blogger Sam advocates from his "Christian Belief" viewpoint is pure evil at evils basest level.
Once we fought and defeated abject evil, Nazism. Now; it seems we have this same evil flowing in our very midst.
We are at the 25 year anniversary of the attacks of 9/11. Here's a question from a conservative blogger who regularly bemoans the lack of Muslim leaders and even everyday followers of Islam to speak out about the violence and support the US...
ReplyDelete"If Muslims are SO hurt by reactions to 9/11, WHERE ARE THEY? HAS any of us seen a pro America rally BY MUSLIMS? EVER? Other than Dr Zuhdi Jasser [an acquaintance of the blogger], I have not heard ONE MUSLIM speak out for America, against the Muslim terrorists."
In Dearborn, Michigan, thousands of residents gathered after the attacks at the Arab American National Museum and local community centers holding American flags, waving unity banners, and raising money for the families of fallen New York first responders.
The Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) and many local mosques organized nationwide blood drives supporting local hospitals and the Red Cross.
In Ann Arbor, Michigan, the Muslim Community Association co-sponsored public "Circles of Peace" where hundreds of citizens held hands surrounding public spaces to demonstrate unified national resilience.
Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat publicly and visibly donated blood at a hospital in Gaza explicitly earmarked for wounded American survivors to signal absolute condemnation of the violence.
In Iran, at great risk, thousands of young Iranian Muslims spontaneously poured into the streets of northern Tehran on September 18, 2001 in support of the US and in condemnation of the terrorist attacks.
But she's never heard of any of these events.
Following up in response to the frequent charge from conservatives like "Sam Huntington", here are numerous of Muslim leaders and groups from around the world who indeed spoke up, often at great personal peril to condemn the violence of 9/11.
ReplyDeleteMuhammad Ali... said "I am a Muslim. I am an American. If the culprits are Muslim, they have twisted the teachings of Islam. Whoever performed the terrorist attacks does not represent Islam. God is not behind assassins.
Mustafa Mashhur… The General Guide and top leader of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood at the time.
Dr. Muhammad Salim al-Awa… A highly influential Egyptian legal scholar, Islamic thinker, and intellectual who helped draft and authorize the theological language used in publicly condemning the attacks.
Tariq al-Bishri… A respected Egyptian judge, jurist, and former head of the Egyptian State Council joined in the condemnation of the attacks.
Qazi Hussain Ahmed… The Ameer (Top Leader) of Jamaat-e-Islami Pakistan, which was the largest and most influential mainstream Islamist political party in Pakistan.
Fadzil Noor (Fazil Nour)… The President of PAS (Parti Islam Se-Malaysia), Malaysia's primary Islamic political party.
Grand Mufti Abdul-Aziz Al-Sheikh (Saudi Arabia)... Declared 9/11 a "grave crime" and asserted that hijacking planes and terrorizing civilians are wholly un-Islamic acts strictly forbidden by Sharia law.
Convened by King Abdullah II of Jordan, 200 of the world’s leading Islamic scholars issued a declaration, The Amman Message, forbidding the practice of takfir (declaring other Muslims apostates), which extremists use to justify murdering civilians.
The American Muslim Political Coordination Committee (AMPCC), representing a coalition of major political groups, released a unified statement echoing that American Muslims utterly rejected and condemned the terrorism executed that day.
The Islamic Society of North America (ISNA) immediately condemned the 9/11 events as "mindless violence”
The Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) hours after the World Trade Center towers were hit on September 11 issued a statement calling the actions "vicious and cowardly acts of terrorism against innocent civilians”.
Sheikh Yusuf al-Qaradawi (Chairman of the Sunna and Sira Council in Qatar) and Sheikh Taha Jabir al-Alwani (Chairman of the North America Fiqh Council), issued a joint fatwa condemning the violence and terrorism.
Dr. Muhammad Tahir-ul-Qadri’s issued a 600-Page Fatwa condemning the violence. Titled the Fatwa on Terrorism and Suicide Bombings, the 600 page paper systematically dismantled Al-Qaeda's ideology, stating without any "ifs or buts" that terrorists are "heroes of hellfire" rather than martyrs.
A simple google search would have shown anyone that many, many Muslims spoke out and condemned the 9/11 attacks. However, there are people who do not want to have their pet prejudices destroyed with facts.
DeletePS. "Sam Huntington" would like to nuke every Muslim on the planet. Apparently he'd approve of nuking certain American cities where hundreds of thousands of Muslim Americans live?
I don't think his bigotry thought this through.
Bigotry never thinks. It just feeds the prejudices and hate that a small and pinched mind feeds on.
DeleteIt wasn't because they "hate us for our freedom".
ReplyDeletehttps://www.history.com/articles/al-qaeda
In 1996, bin Laden announced a fatwa against the United States, “Declaration of War Against the Americans Occupying the Land of the Two Holy Places,” with a second declaration of fatwa issued in 1998, citing protests against the United States, Israel and other allies.
“The U.S. today, as a result of the arrogant atmosphere, has set a double standard, calling whoever goes against its injustice a terrorist,” bin Laden said in a 1997 interview with CNN. “It wants to occupy our countries, steal our resources, impose on us agents to rule us, and then wants us to agree to all this.”
It was the inevitable clash between American imperialism partnered with belligerent Israeli Zionism and radical fundamentalist Muslim nationalism.
Religious extremism and avarice are perpetual breeders of hate, violence, and suffering.
Sadly, this is the human condition.
DeleteWhat can we take from my two previous comments, in light of the question from the blogger I quoted and “Sam Huntington”?
ReplyDeleteI for one shake my head.
The evidence is there and easy to access. We can read the statements some people persist in saying do not exist. In some cases we can, through audio and YouTube files, hear and see the leaders I have cited publicly condemning the violence of 9/11.
We can access news reports from those days after the attacks where, in places like Dearborn and Ann Arbor, we see American Muslims standing and demonstrating in solidarity with their country.
And yet, even confronted with that evidence, some continue to refer to Muslims as “vermin,” or deliberately use terms like “Moslem” as a way of denigrating them.
At this point, we can't get angry.
But we should be sad that some in our country have decided to ignore facts, reality and evidence simply to continue to hate their fellow man.
A group of Muslims carried out a heinous act against the United States on 9/11. We should condemn what they did. But we should not condemn all Muslims because of it. And saying that Muslims never spoke out against the violence of that day is simply factually incorrect.
Muslims have extremists. Christians have extremists. Jews have extremists. Every great religious tradition has people who have used their faith to justify hatred, violence and even murder.
But we don't judge an entire faith—or millions of people who practice it—by its extremists. At least we shouldn't.
Christians certainly don't want Christianity judged by the worst things Christians have done in the name of God. We should extend that same grace and intellectual honesty to our Muslim neighbors.
Christians have, at various times in history, acted in what they believed was righteous obedience to God and killed others “in defense of the faith.”
Christian theology was used to justify slavery. It was invoked in the conquest, dispossession and forced assimilation of Indigenous peoples. The Doctrine of Discovery gave theological cover to the seizure of lands and the subjugation of Indigenous people around the world.
Christian extremists have bombed and burned medical clinics serving women and performing abortions, and some have even murdered doctors, claiming they were acting in obedience to God.
And this is before we even get to the Crusades.
Yet when someone points to those things and says, “This is Christianity. This is what Christians are,” Christians rightly object.
We say that's not fair. You cannot judge Jesus, the Gospel or millions of Christians by the worst things done by people claiming the Christian name.
Then we owe Muslims the same intellectual and moral fairness.
This isn't an argument that Christianity and Islam are the same. They aren't. It isn't an argument that Islamic extremism isn't real. It clearly is. And it certainly isn't an argument that we should somehow minimize the horror of what happened on September 11.
It's much simpler than that.
The original question was... Where were the Muslims? Where were the Muslims who spoke out against the terrorists and stood with America after 9/11?
They were there.
They spoke.
They condemned the attacks.
They mourned alongside their fellow Americans.
And the historical record proves it.
So perhaps the question now isn't whether the evidence exists.
The question is what we're willing to do with that evidence when it challenges something we have already decided to believe.
Because we have an obligation to tell the truth... even when the truth complicates the story we would prefer to believe.
And perhaps especially then.
Make it stop!
ReplyDeleteA blogger wrote about her experience in an American church in France on 9/11...
"An old woman was sitting to my right, sobbing……I put my arm around her. A beautiful young women on my left asked if I was American… I told her I was…she said 'Today, Madame, we are ALL Americans!' "
That is how it was. And it remained so as our military entered Afghanistan to deal with the masterminds and planners of the terrorist attacks of 9/11.
But then we attacked Iraq, a country that, according to the evidence, had no involvement in those attacks. Additionally, they had no useful WMD's according to information that ultimately came from the attacking US administration.
We believed they did. But they did not.
And then came the backlash against Muslims, the great majority of whom practice their religion peacefully, just like believers in other religions around the globe.
Soon we had the policies and belligerence of POTUS Trump, publicly berating longtime democratic US Allies while praising Putin, Xi and Kim Jong Un, dictators all.
Then we started removing sanctions from the "axis of evil" countries and putting essentially sanctions, in the form of tariffs, on our staunchest allies.
Countries who sent men and women to fight alongside us and die in defense of the US after 9/11.
England, Germany, Italy, Canada and more.
I doubt we will hear "we are all Americans" again anytime soon.
In 25 years, primarily through the actions of two US presidents, we have squandered decades of goodwill and a reservoir of respect and admiration from around the globe, from our allies and more.
Who knew then that the hell of 9/11 would still be with us today.
As with Iraq, we are once again acting.
ReplyDeleteDriven by the Zionist sponsored hate against Arabs and Persians.
Iran has never been a threat to the US. The very religion they practice and revere is against nuclear weapons. Contrary to the lies of the butcher netanyahu and his Zionist government, and, our ignorant and destructive potus.
Reading the entire Old Testament I grew to understand why Arabs and others at that time in history, and going forward, distrusted and we're and are suspicious of Jews.
The problems in the ME are the direct result of western interference and manipulation in the Middle East...
The sooner the west recognizes,acknowledges, and starts acting differently the quicker the problems will evaporate.
I for one am not holding my breath.
Nor am I.
Delete"Sam Huntington was a prominent Poly Sci professor, not to be confused with
ReplyDeletethe“pseudonymous” Sam who obfuscates the ship of fools. Nuff said
And the purposeful inanity and dare I say it, willful hate, continues.
ReplyDeleteLook at my lists above. Shaw, you are correct. A simple Google search will reveal the truth of what I posted. But apparently that is too much work, or carries too much risk of dislodging deeply imbedded racism, hate and bigotry.
Here's a comment today from a person who professes love for America and her fellow man...
A young man who apparently lost a family member [at 9/11] said this: "I HAVE HAD TO LIVE WITH PEOPLE TAKING 9/11 AS AN OPPORTUNITY TO INSULT AND SLAM OUR MUSLIM BROHERS AND SISTERS. THIS HAS TO STOP."
We will live in constant vigilance if more morons like the young man feel this way; and plenty do. Congratulations, Islam. I guess I missed the occasion where Muslims rose and stood against the terror brought on by their beliefs.
Yes... I guess she did, I guess she did.
Is it willful ignorance?
I believe it is...
Geeez and her pals on the Mother Ship are plain, old fashioned anti-Muslim bigots. Her statement: "We will live in constant vigilance if more morons like the young man feel this way; and plenty do." exemplifies why the young man and millions of Muslim Americans live in fear. She's part of the problem, and has no self-awareness of what her words say about her rank bigotry.
DeleteSo if we all went to a Moslem country, we'd find reciprocity in treatment for people with different cultural beliefs. Women? Gays?
ReplyDeletebtw- European colionization was largely responsible for ending the jizya is Moslem countries. Same for slavery.
If you visited Indonesia, the country with the largest Moslem population, yes, but not gays. But our supposed advanced, SECULAR country only VERY RECENTLY DECRIMINALIZED HOMOSEXUALITY AND DESCRIMINATION AGAINST GAYS. Maybe some of the Muslim countries will catch up with the US and do the same.
DeleteJust for your information, some fundamental Christians have stated that homosexuals should be banned from teaching and some fanatical clergy have called for the killing of all homosexuals. So, in some areas of our religious culture, the treatment of gays is still considered a crime, just like it is in Moslem countries. (See below this comment.)
The United States stopped making private same-sex sexual activity illegal nationwide in 2003, and banned workplace discrimination nationwide based on sexual orientation in 2020.
"Indianapolis, Indiana (2025): During a men's preaching event at the Sure Foundation Baptist Church, a speaker named Steven Falco stated that LGBTQ+ individuals were worthy of death and should be executed by the government or commit suicide. The church later defended the remarks, claiming they advocated for state-sanctioned capital punishment rather than vigilante action."
DeleteSacramento, California (2016): Following the Pulse nightclub shooting in Orlando, Faithful Word Baptist Church pastor Roger Jimenez stated in a sermon that the victims "deserved to die" and argued that a righteous government should execute gay people. Other extremist pastors, including Steven Anderson of Arizona, made similar comments.
Arlington, Texas (2022): Steadfast Baptist Church pastor Dylan Oz stated during a sermon that gay people should be tried and put to death by being shot in the back of the head."
Anon asked... "So if we all went to a Moslem country, we'd find reciprocity in treatment for people with different cultural beliefs. Women? Gays?"
DeleteI don't know. But what's the point? The US has always held itself up as an "Exceptional Nation" better than others. As such, since we've defined ourselves, we're held to a higher standard.
Look, the thrust of the post was the blindness and bigotry of some of the people in our country who find themselves and America as they imagine it, as exceptional.
And so Shaw and I highlighted some of their views.
Which as you can see, are anything but enlightened or exceptional.
I've been to Indonesia.
DeleteIndonesia is not an Islamic state. It does not crown Islam as the official state religion, and national governance is not founded on Islamic law (Sharia).
DeleteInstead, the nation is guided by Pancasila, the official state ideology. Its first pillar dictates a "Belief in the One and Only God," which provides a religion-friendly framework while remaining inclusive. The state officially recognizes and protects six formal religions: Islam, Protestantism, Catholicism, Hinduism, Buddhism, and Confucianism
You proved my point. If you're the "Anonymous" above. The question was:
Delete"So if we all went to a Moslem country, we'd find reciprocity in treatment for people with different cultural beliefs. Women? Gays?"
And I said Indonesia is the largest Muslim country and does allow reciprocity in treatment for people with different cultural or religious beliefs.
Except for their treatment of gays.
And Christianity is legally allowed and officially recognized in Indonesia.
Indonesia guarantees freedom of worship in its constitution.
The government officially recognizes both Protestantism and Catholicism as two of the country's six approved religions.
Christians make up over 10% of the total population, representing more than 30 million people.
So in the world's most populous Muslim country, other cultures and religions are welcomed.
lol!
DeleteSharia in Aceh
Special Autonomy: Following a 2005 peace agreement, Aceh received special autonomous status allowing it to enforce regional Islamic bylaws (Qanun).
Enforcement & Policing: Sharia courts (Mahkamah Syar'iyah) and a dedicated Sharia police force (Wilayatul Hisbah) monitor public behavior and enforce local ordinances.
Prohibitions & Penalties: Rules cover modest dress codes, bans on alcohol and gambling, restrictions on unmarried couples being in close proximity (khalwat), and criminal penalties for same-sex relations.
Corporal Punishment: Aceh is known for carrying out public caning or flogging for violations of its Islamic criminal code.
Non-Muslims: Sharia criminal bylaws generally apply to Muslims, though certain violations like gambling or selling alcohol can impact non-Muslims under specific conditions.
Corporal punishment in Singapore and Indonesia involves judicial or school caning and whipping, with Singapore applying it nationwide for criminal offenses and severe school discipline, and Indonesia limiting public caning to Aceh Province under Sharia law.
DeleteSingapore: Caning Laws and Rules
Singapore uses caning as both a legal penalty and a school disciplinary measure.
Judicial Caning: Details on offenses and execution are outlined in Caning in Singapore. It is mandatory or optional for over 35 offenses, including vandalism, robbery, and drug trafficking, and applies strictly to males.
School Caning: Updated guidelines permit schools to use between one and three strokes of the cane as a last resort for severe misconduct, such as bullying.
Restrictions: School caning applies only to boys aged nine and older. Girls are entirely exempt due to national legal codes.
Indonesia: Sharia Flogging in Aceh
Indonesia does not use corporal punishment nationwide, but it is legal and active in specific regions.
Regional Enforcement: Judicial caning and whipping are used in Aceh Province, which operates under special Islamic Sharia law.
Offenses: Punishments are publicly administered for offenses like gambling, drinking alcohol, and sex outside marriage.
Execution: Unlike Singapore, these floggings apply to both men and women, who are usually struck across the upper back while wearing a shirt.
International Reception
Human Rights Criticism: Global organizations like the World Health Organization and Amnesty International criticize these punishments as inhumane.
Local Defense: Both governments maintain that physical deterrence protects social order and keeps crime rates low.
Indonesia seemed to me the most impoverished nation in Asia. Singapore, renowned for its economy, was the most corrupt. A boarding party of Singapore's finest ransacked crew staterooms and stole money and jewelry, broke the seals on bonded stores, and confiscated all the liquor on board. When they left, they were all popping open beers on their police launch. In order to leave Singapore, we had to bribe the harbormaster with cigarettes and porn. Wonderful Place.
DeleteIn Singapore, the connection between Malay identity and Islam is deeply profound, to the extent that the two are considered almost inseparable culturally, socially, and legally.
The Core Connection: "To Be Malay is to Be Muslim"
Demographic Overlap: An overwhelming 98.8% of ethnic Malays in Singapore identify as Muslim. This massive correlation means that nearly all Malay cultural traditions, rites of passage, and social norms are viewed through an Islamic lens.
Indigeneity: The Constitution of Singapore officially recognizes Malays as the indigenous people of the country. Their historic presence predates British colonization, tying the roots of Singapore’s cultural landscape directly to the broader Islamic history of the Malay Archipelago.
from Wikipedia:
DeleteTerrorism in Indonesia refer to acts of terrorism that take place within Indonesia or attacks on Indonesian people or interests abroad. These acts of terrorism often target the government of Indonesia or foreigners in Indonesia, most notably Western visitors, especially those from the United States and Australia.
AI Overview:
DeleteThe United States has a vastly higher violent crime rate than Singapore. Across every major category of violent crime—including homicide, armed robbery, and assault—the metrics in the United States outpace those in Singapore by substantial margins.
SOURCES: (https://frostandsullivaninstitute.org/the-preventable-crime-understanding-global-homicide-the-us-challenge-and-the-singapore-exception/), [2] (https://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/compare/Singapore/United-States/Crime)
Singapore utilizes a strict penal code with severe deterrents for violent acts and drug trafficking, including corporal punishment (caning) and capital punishment.
The U.S. legal system varies widely by state and relies on different prison sentencing structures, resulting in a significantly larger per capita prison population but higher recurring rates of violent offenses.
You haven't addressed the subject of this post and how AI deconstructed "Sam Huntington's" vile genocidal statement on Muslims.
Why?
I will NOT publish anything more on Singapore, which has nothing to do with this post.
You want to be critical of the US out of context and hold it to some standard of perfection, that's your business. I simply ask you to apply the same standard to the Islamic countries from which they came. You'll discover that the values being optimized are different and incommensurable. And yes, Islam is incommensurable in an Islamic shari'a based country with Western values. Even in Indonesia, the "least Islamic" (never conquered) of them.
DeleteYou can't compare the two systems of government because of the cultural and religious differences: Western individualistic cultures and Eastern/collectivist cultures. But you CAN compare the level of violence under each one, and that's what I did. You see it as my being critical when I merely stated the actual numbers.
DeleteI prefer the American system, but I also understand that it is not perfect -- or any more perfect than the Eastern/collectivist system. Both of them have to deal with their criminals and both of them, IMO, have their flaws.
The Eastern/Muslim countries use non-universal human rights punishments for non-capital crimes (apostasy, for example, and drug dealing -- although Trump has advocated the death penalty, like the Muslim countries, and actually instituted death penalties in international waters!)
We just throw everyone in prison. We have the largest prison population on the planet. (Or we kill people while being Black and shoot innocent Americans in their streets.)
Shaw... someone anonymously, probably from here, posted on the Mothership what I presented here, that there were in fact many Muslims who spoke up. Like she did back in the day when she would rail against Obama for not speaking against the gangsta culture in the black communities and was presented worth proof, she just denied it.
ReplyDeleteWith this lovely quote...
"ANONYMOUS: No they did not, not in any meaningful numbers. It would actually be against the Quran to speak out against it.
Because of course, she a scholar of the Quran, and knows all.
Lord, make it stop.
The lord will not make it stop. Were that possible, or if she cared to, it would have already stopped.
DeleteIf there is a supreme creator being with a son who took human birth everything humans need to act ethically and morally is within us. Which is to say it is our responsibility to create the world that IS possible, if we really wanted it.
After all these years, with humans creating ever more efficient means to create chaos and destruction, it is doubtful it will ever stop.
If alien brothers and sisters have observed humanity on earth and the inhumanity it seems to revel in, they would stay as far as as possible from ever encountering us.
Dave, that Anonymous was me. I was so angry with that post, I let my Sicilian temper get the better of me. I didn't think she'd post it, though.😏
DeleteAgain, a simple google would have shown her that she is WRONG about what it says in the Quran:
The Quran and Innocent Life
The Quran forbids the killing of innocent people.
Islamic teachings state that taking one innocent life is like killing all of humanity (Surah Al-Ma'idah 5:32).
The Quran teaches justice and truth, meaning condemning mass murder aligns directly with core Islamic principles.
Muslim Condemnation of 9/11
Countless Islamic scholars, organizations, and ordinary Muslims worldwide immediately condemned the 9/11 attacks as violations of Islamic law.
Major Islamic groups issued formal statements and fatwas (legal rulings) clarifying that terrorism and the
Muslims and Islamic leaders worldwide overwhelmingly condemned the 9/11 terrorist attacks, explicitly pointing out that the Quran strictly forbids the killing of innocent people. [1] (https://kurzman.unc.edu/islamic-statements-against-terrorism/), [2] (https://www.whyislam.org/worldwide-condemnation-of-terrorism/).
Immediate Public CondemnationsI
n the hours and days following September 11, 2001, major Muslim organizations, clerics, and political groups issued decisive statements:
American Muslim Organizations: Within hours of the attacks, the American Muslim Political Coordination Council (AMPCC) (representing groups like CAIR, AMC, and AMA) issued a statement declaring: "American Muslims utterly condemn what are vicious and cowardly acts of terrorism against innocent civilians... No political cause could ever be assisted by such immoral acts."
Global Islamic Scholars: Prominent international figures, including Egypt's Grand Mufti and Qatar-based scholar Sheikh Yusuf al-Qaradawi, issued an official fatwa (religious ruling) condemning the attacks. Qaradawi stated: "Islam, the religion of tolerance, considers the killing of innocent people a heinous crime."
And, again, she and her commenters don't want the truth. Apparently, their bigotry around Muslims is too precious for them to let go of.
Understandable Shaw. Understandable. There are some people who only want to deal in "facts" that agree with their own already deeply held positions.
DeleteWe're all like that to some degree.
The American myth [story for those of you from Rio Lindo] is a powerful drug.
We're self reliant, blessed by God, given this wonderful land to work, exercise dominion and build a City on a Hill. And we can do whatever we need or desire to make it so.
Add in slavery was good, it was ordained by God, we saved the world in WWII, American Exceptionalism and you end up with a toxic stew.
From people who I believe truly love America.
Then there's the other side.
As settlers, we took the land from the Native Americans. Instead of coming as guests, we took the house when they weren't looking. Then killed them for complaining. We built the biggest industrial and economic base in the world, on the backs of slaves. And our fruits and vegetables are mostly picked by low wage Latinos, willing to do anything to support their families.
We subjugated the rights of women, POC, our original inhabitants and more, often in the name of a loving God, Manifest Destiny and the Doctrine of Discovery.
Currently, we just can't reconcile those two sides of the American coin.
And sometimes that paradox gets to us. It's often best to just let it go.
This is why the US cannot have nice things any longer... Because people like "Sam Huntington", the one highlighted in this post, when faced with the statement that many Muslims stood up and protested the violence of 9/11, responded with this...
ReplyDeleteOkay, Anonymous .. may I call you Moron? Name one Muslim who condemned the 9/11 attacks.
My gosh, in the thread alone we have at least 13 different major Muslim leaders from around the globe and numerous organizations representing millions of Muslims. And that's before the Iranian Muslims who protested after 9/11 in support of America are counted.
These are simply verifiable facts.
Again, willful ignorance. From today's featured bigot.
People who have no good arguments and who've been correctly called out as a bigot for advocating genocide for 1.3 billion people often resort to ad hominem attacks because that's all they've got. They've been caught and rightly shown to be bigots, and, as Montaigne would have said, more barbaric than their enemies they attack.
DeleteCIA interference in Iran was bad... so how does political assassination compare?
DeleteSome historical accounts and memoirs suggest that elements of Mosaddegh's political coalition, the National Front, held clandestine meetings with Fadayan-e Islam right before the murder to coordinate opposition against Razmara. While it is heavily debated whether Mosaddegh directly authorized or knew of the plot, the assassination perfectly served the National Front's political goals.
3. Condoning and Pardoning the Assassin.
After Mosaddegh became Prime Minister, his government treated the assassin as a national hero rather than a criminal. In 1952, the Mosaddegh-aligned Iranian Parliament officially passed a bill pardoning Tahmasebi. The bill explicitly stated that because Razmara was guilty of "treason" and supporting foreigners, his killer was innocent.
The human beast. We ponder 78,000 deaths in Gaza, civilians mostly and whole cities without a building left standing. My daughter was teaching at West Point on 9-11. I was almost a year old when the sneak attack on Peral Harbor took place. There is a lurking underside to the human animal, unique among the mammals. shame on us.
ReplyDeleteYet there is a path to realizing permenant peace and happiness. But to acheive both requires recognizing the ultimate truth of emptiness. Emptiness is form and form is emptiness. Emptiness is none other than form amf form non other than emptiness.. Combined with an understanding that all composite phenomenon or impermanent peace and happiness on a sustained basis is possible.
ReplyDeleteYet we humans work diligently through our aversions and attachments to what reality actually is to realize sustained peace and happiness. Letting go of the illusions created by our human misperceptins is neccessary to achieving peace and happiness.
Think of life as dreamlike, even during our waking hours.
Row row row your boat gently down the stream.
Merrily merrily merrily merrily life is but a dream..
It's simple. But it isn't easy.
-FJ posted this... "You want to be critical of the US out of context and hold it to some standard of perfection, that's your business. I simply ask you to apply the same standard to the Islamic countries from which they came.."
ReplyDeleteNo! No, no, a thousand times no!
I get it -FJ, you, Geeez, Mustang, Sam and the rest of the crew of the Mothership don't want us judged by the ideal we've always held out for ourselves.
But it literally is that ideal that makes, or made America great.
We've always believed we were better, could do anything, had that certain American je ne said quoi, swagger.
Even when we've fallen short or our lofty goals, intentions and hopes.
Seriously, are you arguing for judging America by the standards of places Trump and your friends call shithole countries?
No wonder we're at each others throats in this country.
What are you talking about, M? The America you idolize has overthrown hundreds of democracies. The CIA overthrows them seven days a week. And how do they do that? By following Alexanders example. Old Italian proverb: "Alexander never did what he said, and Caesar never said what he did."
DeleteThe "ideal" is the lie. Trump is simply refusing to repeat the noble lie. He's offering the world a deal, and members of his "Board of Peace" have taken him up on it. The deal is, we'll stop lying AND we'll stop internally subverting your populations with that "old noble lie" woke bs. He's taking us back to Realpolitique. Protego ergo Obligo. He killed the USAID structure that kept the world in-line with a knife to every government's throat that said, "Do as we say or we'll start a colour revolution in your country."
Your problem is that you still want people to believe in your woke "noble lie".... You still believe in it.
Our "noble lie" is the American economic system. It's NOT global neoliberalism. It's the economic and political system of the Federalist Papers.
I'm talking about reality -FJ... You've asserted hundreds of democracies have been overthrown by the US. Care to offer any proof of that? Certainly many, but hundreds? Hyperbole.
DeleteAs for Realpolitik, I think our leaders knew what they were doing. Reality gave us the Marshall Plan, the economic backbone that enabled Europe to rebuild after WWII and helped establish the longest stretch of economic growth and mostly peace we've ever seen.
Add in democracy in Japan and South Korea and the results are not as uniformly bad as you assert.
Certainly recently, someone can make some claims about the idiocy of US foreign policy, but let's check those parties. Kennedy and Ike got the ball rolling SE Asia, but JFK planned to get us out of dodge after the elections. But... well, Oswald.
Nixon pressed the war and between all of those admins, we had a buch of damn liars running the ship.
Ronald "we don't negotiate with terrorists" Reagan wasn't much help, Bush I went in and got out, Clinton dallied in Eastern Europe, but that was peanuts compared to Bush II.
We're not perfect and no one has ever asserted that, certainly not here.
In fact, most of us want the crappy stuff out in the open. It's not people like me and Shaw who would rather not have people knowing this, lest they 'hate America". It's your fellow sailors on the Mothership.
Why don't you try putting this paragraph of yours over there on that sight and see what happens?
The America you idolize [Ms Z] has overthrown hundreds of democracies. The CIA overthrows them seven days a week. And how do they do that? By following Alexanders example. Old Italian proverb: "Alexander never did what he said, and Caesar never said what he did."
Goo ahead, give it a try.
I'll just end with this... your statement "The "ideal" is the lie. Trump is simply refusing to repeat the noble lie. He's offering the world a deal, and members of his "Board of Peace" have taken him up on it. The deal is, we'll stop lying AND we'll stop internally subverting your populations with that "old noble lie" woke bs. is comical.
If you think anyone or anything is going to stop Trump from lying, man, you're smoking some strong hopium.
The. USA has been a colonial and imperial republic guided by the exploitive and manipulative desires of the capitalist class since at least 1945. But considering the treatment of the indigenous natives and the attempts to eliminate them, one sees it actually goes back to our beginnings.
ReplyDeleteThe balance of your comment flys in the face of the MAGA Fuhrer's observed actions and many statements that confirm tge MAGA Fuhrer is indeed possesses a colonizers and imperialist mentality.